Murray overtime penalty kick lifts Ellicottville past North Collins

Recap Girls Soccer

WNY Athletics Staff · October 29, 2026

Overview

Ellicottville defeated North Collins 2-1 in overtime on Oct. 28 in Hamburg.
Eliza Murray scored in the first half and converted a penalty kick with 8:54 remaining in overtime.
Ady Andrews made six saves for Ellicottville.
Ellicottville improved to 9-6-1, while North Collins moved to 6-8-3.

Eliza Murray converted a penalty kick in overtime for her second goal of the game, giving Ellicottville a 2-1 girls soccer victory over North Collins on Oct. 28 in Hamburg.

Murray scored with 18:30 remaining in the first half, and the teams were tied 1-1 at halftime. Neither side scored in the second half, sending the game to overtime.

With 8:54 remaining in overtime, Murray scored on a penalty kick to provide the deciding goal. Murray had nine goals for the season through the contest, including three penalty-kick goals.

Ady Andrews made six saves on seven shots faced for Ellicottville.

Ellicottville improved to 9-6-1 overall and stood third in CCAA 2 with a 6-4 division record. North Collins moved to 6-8-3 overall and stood fourth in CCAA 3 at 4-5-1.

Standings through Oct. 28

CCAA 3 (division)

Rank	Team	Overall	Division	PF	PA
1	Frewsburg	15-3	10-0	78	19
2	Silver Creek/Forestville	11-6-1	6-3-1	53	34
3	Westfield/Brocton	5-8-2	4-4-2	12	29
4	North Collins	6-8-3	4-5-1	29	27
5	Chautauqua Lake	4-10-2	3-5-2	19	62
6	Dunkirk	2-15	0-10	15	74

CCAA 2 (division)

Rank	Team	Overall	Division	PF	PA
1	Randolph	12-4	10-0	62	14
2	Salamanca	14-4	8-2	69	19
3	Ellicottville	9-6-1	6-4	42	21
4	Catt. Little Valley	4-11-1	4-6	14	40
5	Franklinville	4-12	2-8	26	53
6	Pine Valley/Gowanda	0-11	0-9	1	94